Employment & HR Compliance in Japan

Working Hours Compliance in Japan: 36 Agreements and Management Supervisor Risk

  • Hirohide Nakagawa, Tokyo Startup Law Firm

Two important working-hours compliance risks for foreign companies operating in Japan are the management of Article 36 Agreements and the classification of employees as management supervisors.

Both risks are frequently underestimated. Article 36 Agreements require ongoing management: they must be properly filed, renewed, and monitored against statutory limits. Management supervisor classification is an area where domestic companies with long-established practices have found themselves exposed, and foreign companies — sometimes applying global frameworks for senior roles — face the same risk.

This article explains how each of these areas works, where compliance problems commonly arise, and what foreign companies operating in Japan should be doing to manage the risk.

What a 36 Agreement Does — and What It Does Not Do

Japan’s Labor Standards Act prohibits work beyond statutory hours (eight hours per day, forty hours per week) and work on statutory rest days unless the employer has a written agreement with the relevant labor representatives — commonly called a “36 Agreement” after the statutory provision that authorizes it — and files that agreement with the competent Labor Standards Inspection Office.

A 36 Agreement does not authorize unlimited overtime. It authorizes overtime up to the limits it specifies, which must fall within the statutory caps. The agreement must be renewed — typically annually — and filed again with each renewal. An agreement that has expired is not effective.

The 2019 amendments to the Labor Standards Act introduced hard statutory upper limits on overtime that apply regardless of what a 36 Agreement says:

  • Monthly: The combined total of overtime and statutory holiday work must remain strictly below 100 hours per month
  • Annual: 720 hours (excluding holiday work)
  • Average over any 2–6 month period: 80 hours per month (including holiday work)
  • Standard monthly limit: 45 hours (extendable under a special provision clause, but subject to the caps above)

A 36 Agreement may include a special provision clause (特別条項) authorizing higher overtime in peak periods, but only up to six times per year, and always subject to the absolute monthly and annual caps. The caps introduced in 2019 are statutory ceilings: a 36 Agreement cannot authorize overtime above them, and any overtime worked above them exposes the employer to criminal liability under the Labor Standards Act.

Foreign companies should verify that their current 36 Agreement is valid (not expired), has been filed with the relevant Labor Standards Inspection Office, and that the limits it specifies — and the actual hours worked — fall within the statutory caps. For a broader overview of Japan’s overtime and working-hours rules, see Japanese Overtime, Working Hours, and Paid Leave Regulations Explained.

Common Compliance Gaps in 36 Agreement Management

Several compliance gaps arise frequently in practice.

The agreement has not been renewed. A 36 Agreement covers a defined period. If it expires and is not renewed before the expiration date, no valid agreement is in place for the period after expiration. Any overtime worked in that period is unauthorized under the Labor Standards Act regardless of whether employees continue working the same hours.

The representative executing the agreement does not satisfy the legal requirement. A 36 Agreement must be concluded with either a labor union with majority membership in the workplace or, where no such union exists, a person elected to represent the majority of employees. If the representative was not properly designated — for example, if management appointed a representative or the election process was not properly conducted — the agreement may not be valid.

Hours actually worked exceed the agreement’s limits. A valid 36 Agreement authorizes overtime up to specified limits. If the hours employees actually work exceed those limits — even if the limits are within the statutory caps — the excess hours are unauthorized. Employers need monitoring systems that track both the agreement’s limits and actual hours worked across departments and individuals.

The agreement does not cover all relevant workplaces or employee categories. A 36 Agreement must be filed with the Labor Standards Inspection Office with jurisdiction over each workplace. A company with multiple offices may need separate agreements filed in each jurisdiction. Similarly, the agreement’s scope should be reviewed to confirm that all relevant employee categories are covered.

Foreign companies that have not recently reviewed their 36 Agreement arrangements — including the filing history, the designation of labor representatives, and actual-hours monitoring — should treat this as a priority compliance item. Companies reviewing their employment framework more broadly may also find it useful to review their work rules (shūgyō kisoku) at the same time.

The Management Supervisor Exemption: What It Requires and Where It Is Commonly Misapplied

The management supervisor exemption under Article 41(ii) of the Labor Standards Act is an important area of compliance risk for employers in Japan.

Under Article 41(ii), employees who qualify as management supervisors (管理監督者) are exempt from the Act’s overtime and holiday work provisions. Specifically, a company is not required to pay overtime premiums or statutory holiday premiums for these employees. However, the exemption does not cover the late-night work premium (深夜割増賃金) under Article 37(4): management supervisors who work between 10 p.m. and 5 a.m. are entitled to that premium regardless of their exempt status.

Under Japanese case law and administrative guidance, the key factors considered in assessing whether an employee qualifies are: whether the employee has genuine authority over employment conditions and labor management; whether the employee has actual discretion over their working arrangements; and whether the employee receives compensation that reflects their status. These factors are assessed holistically based on the employee’s actual circumstances, not by applying a rigid statutory checklist.

  • On the first factor, genuine authority means actual decision-making power — not nominal authority. Employees who hold a title but whose decisions are routinely subject to approval by others may not satisfy this factor.
  • On the second factor, actual discretion concerns when and how long the employee works. Employees who are required to clock in and out, follow fixed schedules, or whose attendance is tracked in the same way as other employees may not satisfy this factor, depending on the overall facts. Note that time recording for health management purposes (which employers are legally required to conduct) does not by itself indicate that an employee lacks discretion over their working arrangements.
  • On the third factor, compensation must be at a level that is consistent with the scope of the employee’s responsibility and that adequately compensates for the absence of overtime protections.

Japanese courts and the labor authorities apply a substance-over-form approach: an employee designated as a management supervisor who does not actually exercise the required authority and discretion, or who is not compensated at an appropriate level, will not be treated as exempt.

Common misapplications in foreign company settings include: using a global role title (VP, Director, Head of) as a proxy for management supervisor status without a substantive assessment of the relevant factors under Japanese law; applying the exemption to employees whose working arrangements are subject to meaningful managerial oversight or whose operational autonomy is constrained by organizational design; and designating employees as exempt based on compensation levels that, while competitive, do not reflect the scope of a genuinely supervisory role.

The Practical Consequences of Misclassification

If an employee is incorrectly classified as a management supervisor, several consequences follow.

Unpaid overtime. Any overtime hours worked become retroactively compensable at the statutory premium rate (125% of the regular rate for standard overtime; 135% for overtime on statutory holidays). If the employee also worked late nights, the additional late-night premium for those hours would be owed regardless.

Wage claim exposure. Under current Japanese law, wage claims for applicable wages have a limitation period of three years from the date each payment falls due. This three-year period reflects the transitional treatment under the amended Labor Standards Act, which extended the prior two-year period. The potentially recoverable amount and period will depend on the specific circumstances — including when wages became due, how the limitation period applies to each payment, and the facts of the individual situation. For a practical guide to employment contract terms in Japan, see Drafting Employment Contracts in Japan: Must-Have Clauses and Pitfalls.

Regulatory exposure. If the misclassification is identified in a labor inspection, the company may be required to remedy the classification and may be subject to administrative guidance or penalties under the Labor Standards Act. The Labor Standards Inspection Office has authority to require remediation, issue corrective guidance, and refer matters for prosecution in cases involving significant violations.

Reputational and employment-relations risk. Reclassification disputes can surface during employment termination or otherwise become public, and the practical impact on workplace relations should not be underestimated.

Employers who have designated employees as management supervisors should confirm that each designation is supportable on a substantive assessment of the relevant factors, and should consider taking legal advice if there is uncertainty about any classification.

Reviewing Existing Classifications

A structured review of existing management supervisor classifications should assess three things.

First, the factual basis for each classification: does the employee actually exercise authority over employment conditions and labor management in the way the exemption requires? Does the employee have actual discretion over their working arrangements? Is the employee’s compensation at a level that reflects exempt status?

Second, the documentation supporting the classification: what records exist that demonstrate the employee’s authority and discretion? Where records are thin, the factual basis for the classification may be difficult to defend in a dispute or inspection.

Third, the monitoring in place: are time records kept for employees classified as management supervisors? Japanese employers are required to track working hours for health management purposes for all employees, including those who are exempt from overtime provisions. Even for exempt employees, time records support the company’s ability to monitor health risk and demonstrate that management supervisors are genuinely operating outside ordinary operational constraints.

A review of this kind is most useful when conducted with the involvement of qualified Japanese legal counsel who can assess the classifications against the actual legal standard. For foreign companies that have not undertaken such a review, the risk is typically not that any single designation is clearly wrong, but that a cluster of borderline cases — where the exemption was applied on the basis of title or global role rather than a substantive assessment of the relevant factors — creates aggregate exposure.

Practical Steps for Foreign Companies

For Article 36 Agreement compliance:

  • Confirm that a valid, filed 36 Agreement is in place for each workplace.
  • Verify the agreement’s limits against the applicable statutory caps, including the requirement that combined overtime and statutory holiday work remain strictly below 100 hours per month, and the 720-hour annual overtime limit.
  • Check the renewal schedule and set up a process to ensure timely renewal and refiling before each agreement expires.
  • Confirm that the labor representative who executed the agreement was properly designated under the statutory requirements.
  • Implement or review actual-hours monitoring to ensure that hours worked do not exceed the agreement’s limits for any individual employee.

For management supervisor classification:

  • Map current management supervisor designations against the key factors under Japanese case law and administrative guidance — authority, discretion, compensation — on the actual facts.
  • Identify any designations that rely primarily on title, global role framework, or compensation level without a substantive assessment of authority and discretion.
  • Confirm that late-night premium payments are being made for any management supervisors who regularly work between 10 p.m. and 5 a.m.
  • Ensure that time records are kept for all employees, including management supervisors, for health management purposes.
  • Take legal advice on any classification that is uncertain.

Both areas reward early attention: compliance problems in working-hours regulation tend to compound over time, and the cost of remediation is typically higher after an inspection or a claim has been filed than before.

Conclusion

Working-hours compliance in Japan requires ongoing management rather than one-time setup. Article 36 Agreements must be maintained, renewed, monitored, and filed correctly. Management supervisor classifications must reflect the actual facts of each employee’s role, not just their title or compensation level — and the late-night premium applies regardless of exempt status.

Foreign companies that have not recently reviewed either of these areas face a risk that is manageable now but becomes more difficult to address once a problem has surfaced. The practical steps are concrete and achievable. The main requirement is to approach them with advice from qualified Japanese legal counsel who can assess both areas against the applicable legal standards.

If you would like to review your 36 Agreement arrangements or management supervisor classifications in Japan, our team can help you assess the relevant considerations and identify any areas that need attention. → Contact the International Business Desk

WRITTEN BY

Hirohide Nakagawa

Lawyer & author, Tokyo Startup Law Firm

Planning to start a business in Japan?

Book a consultation with our legal team.

Book a Consultation